At the end of September 2026, Wheaton had 51 single-family houses for sale and 34 condos and townhomes. A year earlier the counts were 42 and 18. Across all property types, Midwest Real Estate Data's September Local Market Update for Wheaton puts inventory up 41.7% year over year. Over the same stretch, new listings rose 20.5% and closed sales didn't change.
You might expect that much extra supply to push prices down. It hasn't so far. In September 2026, Wheaton's detached homes sold for 100.2% of their original list price on average, a touch above the 100.0% of September 2025. Average market time dropped from 32 days to 25. Inventory went up because fewer buyers signed contracts. Sellers didn't start a wave of price cuts. For anyone shopping in Wheaton this winter, that means more homes to choose from, and so far no discount on them.
Nine more houses, ten fewer contracts
The detached numbers for September 2026 against September 2025 show where the extra houses came from.
New listings rose from 58 to 62, so only four more houses came on the market. Homes going under contract fell from 40 to 30, a drop of 25%. Closed sales held at 32 both years. Month-end inventory went from 42 to 51.
Sellers did not flood the market. Over the 12 months ending in September 2026, Wheaton's detached new listings actually fell 8.0%, from 640 to 589. The nine extra houses on the September count roughly match the ten contracts that didn't get signed. Listings arrived at about last year's pace, and fewer of them sold within the month. The rest carried into October as inventory.
A home goes under contract before it closes, so the 25% drop in contracts is the earlier signal of the two, and the closing count has not caught up to it yet.
MRED's Wheaton report carries a caution: "Activity for one month can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." Ten contracts is a small number. Treat it as a direction worth following, not a verdict on the market.
Condos and townhomes grew for a different reason
The attached market in Wheaton is where the percentages look big, and the cause is different from the detached side.
From September 2025 to September 2026, attached new listings went from 20 to 32, up 60%. Contracts slipped from 14 to 11, and inventory nearly doubled from 18 to 34. So here it's mostly a supply story. Twelve more condo and townhome owners listed in September than a year earlier, and buyers didn't keep pace.
Prices still went up. The attached median rose from $258,387 to $313,500, and the share of original list price received went from 98.8% to 99.6%. Average market time grew only slightly, from 25 days to 27. Over the full 12 months ending in September 2026, the attached median rose 8.8% to $298,950. Closed sales fell 15.4%, from 208 to 176. Fewer Wheaton condos and townhomes changed hands over the year, and the ones that sold brought more money.
That extra supply is existing homes coming up for resale. New construction isn't driving it. The newest townhome plan in town is eight three-story units proposed at 1701 E. Roosevelt Road. Patch reported the units would run about 1,600 to 1,650 square feet, with three bedrooms and 3.5 baths, and that the proposal was set for Planning and Zoning Commission review on October 13. The Faywell, Banner Real Estate Group's downtown project, is planned as 334 rental units including direct-entry townhomes, with completion expected in the first quarter of 2027, according to JLL. Neither adds for-sale units to this winter's count. The current Wheaton condo listings are where that wider choice shows up.
The September median dropped because a different mix of homes sold
One figure in the report looks like bad news for sellers. Wheaton's detached median sale price fell 12.0% in September 2026, from $597,500 to $526,000.
The average sale price fell 22.1% in the same month, from $788,293 to $613,733. When the average drops much more than the median, a few expensive sales from last September usually have no match this September. Sale prices did fall that month, but homes still closed at 100.2% of original list on average, which fits a change in which homes sold better than a broad cut in what buyers paid. With 32 closings in a month, a handful of upper-bracket sales can swing the average by six figures.
The 12-month figures show the trend. For the 12 months ending in September 2026, Wheaton's detached median was $604,000, up 10.0% from $549,000, and the average was $685,194, up 8.9%. Combine that with sales landing just above original list price, and the September median says more about which houses closed than about where values are going. Our August look at Wheaton's citywide median as several markets averaged together covers why that mix moves so much from month to month.
Wheaton's buildup is the largest nearby, and the cause sets it apart
Neighboring towns' September 2026 reports show whether Wheaton is following a regional trend or doing something of its own.
| September 2026 vs. September 2025 | All-property inventory | Detached under contract | Detached % of original list received |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wheaton | +41.7% | 40 to 30 | 100.0% to 100.2% |
| Warrenville | +40.0% | 12 to 12 | 103.6% to 93.6% |
| Glen Ellyn | +26.9% | 25 to 27 | 104.8% to 101.5% |
| West Chicago | +10.0% | 21 to 14 | 100.6% to 101.5% |
| Carol Stream | -20.4% | 17 to 10 | 100.4% to 99.5% |
| DuPage County | detached +12.1% | 542 to 446 | 99.6% to 98.5% |
Among these towns, Wheaton had the biggest inventory gain. Glen Ellyn's inventory also grew, but its detached contracts rose from 25 to 27 and attached contracts from 7 to 12. That points to more listings meeting steady demand. The price that buyers pay there has softened. Glen Ellyn's detached homes sold for 101.5% of original list, down from 104.8%, and average market time went from 18 days to 28. Warrenville's detached homes sold for 93.6% of original list with an average of 65 days on market, but those figures come from 11 closings.
Wheaton has the reverse pattern. Contracts fell, but the sales that did happen still came in at full price and faster than the county. Across DuPage, detached homes sold for 98.5% of original list in September 2026, with 36 days of average market time and a median of $538,000. A Wheaton house that went under contract in September sold faster and closer to its asking price than a typical DuPage house, even with more competition on the market.
Rates explain the contract slowdown
Mortgage rates are the likeliest reason fewer contracts got signed. Illinois REALTORS reported that Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed commitment rate averaged 6.86% in September 2026, up from 6.67% in August and 6.35% in September 2025. Rates moved higher in the fall and have eased slightly in November. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed at 7.24% on October 29, 7.18% on November 5, and 7.11% on November 12.
The 25% drop in Wheaton contracts happened when rates were still below 7%. Contracts signed in late October and November reflect buyers working with rates above 7%, and MRED's upcoming Wheaton reports will show whether the slowdown continued. Our mortgage calculator lets you compare payments at those rates side by side.
What the numbers mean for a winter search in Wheaton
A Wheaton buyer this winter has more to choose from than last winter. That's true for detached homes and even more so for condos and townhomes. More choice gives you time to compare two or three houses before deciding, and to look at several homes in one weekend.
The numbers don't show a price break yet. Through September 2026, Wheaton sellers were still getting their original list price on average, and their homes sold faster than they did a year earlier. A buyer who waits for the extra inventory to force price cuts is betting that the contract slowdown keeps going and turns into lower prices over the coming months. That could happen. It hasn't shown up in what Wheaton buyers have actually paid.
Individual listings will vary. A house still on the market after the first few weeks, while similar homes sold in about 25 days, is in a different spot than one that went up this week. That gap between a home's days on market and the town's average is where a buyer can negotiate this winter. The citywide percentage won't show it. The current Wheaton listings show how long each home has been available.
The rate and price figures here describe the market on the dates given and are general information, not financial advice. Confirm your own loan terms with your lender. If you own in Wheaton and are wondering how your house would compete against 51 others for fewer buyers this winter, The Lance Kammes Team can compare it with this fall's Wheaton sales and show you where it would land. Start with a free home valuation.